Posted on 01/30/2019 4:35:47 PM PST by RichardMoore
NBC sewing circle now in session. Pass the Venn diagrams and coffee.
SPOT ON; EXACTLY SO!
You are correct. Her parents were permanent residents of the U.S. by the time she was born, she was never a citizen of another country, and a person can not be born a naturalized citizen.
As far as the USSC is concerned, she is a NBC, and they get to make the decision.
There’s no law making children born to foreign nationals, whether here legally or illegally, U.S. citizens. They’re definitely NOT natural born Citizens.
Kamala is a court created citizen(Wong Kim Ark). IOWs a citizen in name only since only Congress has the power of naturalization.
What law passed by congress makes children born to foreign nationals U.S. citizens at birth?
Any lawyer who sues to disqualify her on those grounds is going to lose.
She’s not eligible. It’s that simple.
Said lawyer will probably be disbarred and it is in the realm of possibility that they would be imprisoned on some trumped up charge,
Second, you argue only positive law by legislature can determine citizenship. That position holds Marbury v. Madison in 1803 which established judicial review as illegitimate. How does holding the position that judicial review is invalid help, when it's been accepted for over 200 years?
>> are you a NBC or not?
You!!! lol
NBC is Comcast. None of the Comcast subscribers here at FR are willing to discuss that obscene fact.
They bitch and moan, and bitch and moan about NBC... But God forbid the flakes ever mention Comcast. Assholes.
Courts didn't decide that, policy did.
NBC is they acronym for “natural born citizen”.
“Second, you argue only positive law by legislature can determine citizenship. “
Congress is given sole authority for naturalization by the Constitution. The 14th was for newly freed stateless slaves. Not for naturalizing hordes of foreign nationals in perpetuity under an Amendment.
So going back to my first question, are you a natural born citizen or not? If so, under what law are you a natural born citizen?
“I’m curious then, by the standards you advocate, are you a NBC or not? If so, under what law?”
God’s law—natural law. When 2 bald eagles(U.S. citizens) mate and lay eggs in a eagle’s nest(U.S. soil), what is the natural result? Bald eaglets(NBCs), naturally
When 2 brown-headed cowbirds mate(foreign nationals) and lay eggs in an eagle’s nest(U.S. soil), what is the natural result? Brown-headed cowbirds(foreign nationals) of course.
The idiots guide to natural law.
Oh, BS.
All you birthers claim to have been taught this crap in school yet NOT ONCE has anyone ever cited any school textbook AT ANY TIME that has used your made-up definition of Natural Born Citizen.
-—here we go with this crap again-—all it does is cloud the issue of the socialist agenda.
I agree with you, I just don’t see anyone with power, including President Trump, running with this issue. And I don’t see a major grass-roots movement starting over it. The Kenyan Usurpation has made this a non-issue. The vast majority of people will just settle for “born on US soil” and leave it at that. Including President Trump.
That’s just what I think. That’s just what I predict. That’s just what I mean by “DOA”.
It’s not being left at that.
Ted Cruz was born in Canada to one citizen parent.
Anwar Al-Awlaki’s kids, born in Yemen to one citizen parent are eligible if he is.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.