(Because it’s about me, and uses my writing, I’m going to post the entire AT piece here.)
A fascinating comment on Rick Moran’s blog about the Iranian capture of our sailors is making waves in the blogosphere and on Facebook. It makes a lot more sense than any of the official explanations we have received for the capture and subsequent release of the sailors.
Thomas Lipscomb explains:
Flash! A former Navy SEAL, Matt Bracken, just blew up what I have been calling “a pack of lies from the US and Iran” on what the hell happened that got our boats captured and taken to the Farsi Islands.
Remember: the single most dangerous area in all the Persian Gulf is a small group of Island in almost the middle of the heavily travelled shipping lanes that is a major naval base for Iran and the HQ of the radical IRG for special operations of their own against all the countries abutting the Gulf. A top Marine told me our two boats were special ops boats with crews that delivered our own SEALS... the direct rivals of the IRG on Farsi.
The idea that toxic area would be a possible rendezvous site area for a refueling is idiotic... as is the idea of commo and navigation failure. You might as reasonably expect Gibraltar to be a rendezvous point for resupply for the Nazi subs in Das Boot.
If the US press today weren’t evenly split between toadys and military incoherents, they should have seen what has been clear to anyone who has any military experience.
Here is Matt Bracken’s stunning take:
I rarely pull out my dusty old trident, but in this case, here goes. I was a Navy SEAL officer in the 1980s, and this kind of operation (transiting small boats in foreign waters) was our bread and butter. Today, these boats both not only had radar, but multiple GPS devices, including chart plotters that place your boat’s icon right on the chart. The claim by Iran that the USN boats “strayed into Iranian waters” is complete bull$‪#‎it.
For an open-water transit between nations, the course is studied and planned in advance by the leaders of the Riverine Squadron, with specific attention given to staying wide and clear of any hostile nation’s claimed territorial waters. The boats are given a complete mechanical check before departure, and they have sufficient fuel to accomplish their mission plus extra. If, for some unexplainable and rare circumstance one boat broke down, the other would tow it, that’s why two boats go on these trips and not one! It’s called “self-rescue” and it’s SOP.
This entire situation is in my area of expertise. I can state with complete confidence that both Iran and our own State Department are lying. The boats did not enter Iranian waters. They were overtaken in international waters by Iranian patrol boats that were so superior in both speed and firepower that it became a “hands up!” situation, with automatic cannons in the 40mm to 76mm range pointed at them point-blank. Surrender, hands up, or be blown out of the water. I assume that the Iranians had an English speaker on a loudspeaker to make the demand. This takedown was no accident or coincidence, it was a planned slap across America’s face.
Just watch. The released sailors will be ordered not to say a word about the incident, and the Iranians will have taken every GPS device, chart-plotter etc off the boats, so that we will not be able to prove where our boats were taken.
The “strayed into Iranian waters” story being put out by Iran and our groveling and appeasing State Dept. is utter and complete BS from one end to the other.
Ag the Gates of Vienna, Brian Bodissey passes along an update from Matt Bracken:
I think that the take-down happened in international waters. The Iranians would have known to the minute when the boats were leaving Kuwait, and their probable course to Bahrain, so an intercept would be simple. They know our ROE would be “Do not shoot EVER unless you are fired upon first. PERIOD!!!”
So, if the Iranians jam our boats so they cannot communicate, and then swoop in close, it’s almost a guaranteed outcome. They KNOW we won’t shoot first! So by coming in closer and closer with weapons aimed at our sailors, overwhelming them with numbers at point-blank, then on loudspeaker they say, “Step away from your weapons or we will slaughter you!” At that point, it’s a fait accompli. Once our sailors step back from their guns, it”s over. Next, “Take off your jackets and weapons” etc, until they are in t-shirts only. Then “Kneel down!”
Step by step they get their way, based on a deep understanding of our ROE and our responses at every stage. Once they have control of our boats, they can drive them to Farsi Island, and remove every single GPS device, radar, cell phone etc. Then, there can be no proof of where the attack happened. And worst of all, Obama and Kerry are happy to go along with the lie, in order not to upset the nuclear deal applecart.
Rick Moran points out that one flaw in this scenario is that there was a woman captured, and so far as we know there are no women in Special Forces. He, too, believe that the official story is BS, but that the simple explanation is that the Navy doesn’t want to explain their humiliation and the Obama admininstration wants to keep the Iran deal at all costs.
Hat tips: Clarice Feldman and Cathy Berry Willinger
(Matt Bracken note: Thomas Lifson even “hat tipped” Clarice and Cathy, but he never even contacted me, the guy who wrote the substance of his American Thinker piece!)
Land based or LPD/LPH deployed?
5.56mm
—good one-
-(even though I am far from being a naval expert, the whole thing reeked from the beginning)—
FYI. I heard Michael Savage mention the same wording on his radio show yesterday. I didn’t catch him mentioning Lifson or you. Thanks for your analysis. BTTT!
We have been needing to behead the Islamic Republic since 1979, and now those suicidal bastards are getting nuclear armed ICBMs.
The Russians may have been evil, but they were not lunatics. They wanted to live, and didn't believe that Allah would send them to paradise if they wiped out a Western City.
The Iranians are religious nut-jobs, and starting a Nuclear war is what they WANT to do.
I'm thinking that if the Navy went through there and just blew the f***ing sh*t out of their speed boats, we would either show them not to f*** with us, or start a war. Both outcomes have positive benefits for the nation, but starting a war with these bastards is probably going to work out to be the greater benefit.
In the long run.
Kidding aside, at least he cited you, the hat tip to the two ladies was probably because one of them linked him to your post here. Simplest explanation for him not contacting you begins with a "stupid" and ends in "ity".
Back to the big picture, we all know the story is BS. 0 and Carter (ironic name, don't you think?) tip them off on the position of a couple of our boats they're actually quite welcome to raid, and then the first story used is engine trouble - yeah, right, with two boats. Even I coulda solved that problem.
My conclusion, there was something on those boats that was valuable to the Iranians, plus they got the propaganda coup of the USN being subjected to Islam. (Someone here made that observation first, unfortunately I'm not able to cite them...) What would that something have been? Hey, if I knew, it wouldn't be a secret. Plus they seem to have scored some really cool small arms and stuff. The timing, which obviously coincides with the release of several Americans today and the timetable of the relief of the sanctions on the (*ahem*, plural) add up to circumstantial evidence that the two boats and their crews were just flat-assed given up to be humiliated in that way, particularly the girl sailor being forced by the towelheads to wear a towel on her head.
0 and Kerry were up to something here, and Ash Carter must have some real dirt in his past (yeah, I've heard...) to have played along with it.
Scenario B: Extraction team for some kind of recon operation on Farsi Island or someplace near. I wouldn't know, or claim to know, jack about any of that kind of stuff. Point of the story remains the same, though, given up by 0 and his henchmen...
JMO, with standard caveat, I'm often, even usually full of it if you ax my wife's opinion...
Excellent criticism of the BS we’re being sold.
Thanks for reposting here, and congrats regarding the unexpected recognition.