Book Review: Rise of the Anti-Media by Brian Anse Patrick

Gun Watch ^ | 7 July, 2014 | Dean Weingarten

[marktwain]

The Rise of the Anti-Media is a profound academic examination of how the gun culture has been able to triumph in the face of overwhelming opposition from the ruling elite.   This is not a book that is light summer reading.   The issues examined, the research done, and the theory put forward to explain the phenomena, are worthy of serious study.    Information in the book is dense.  Brian Anse Patrick packs a great deal into only 282 pages.  The book captured my attention.  I devoured it in a day, but find myself repeatedly returning for more insight.

It helps to have been intimately involved in many of the subjects discussed.  Nearly everyone who has been involved in second amendment activism during the last five decades will find themselves nodding in agreement as they read this book.  

Rise of the Anti-Media contains an important historical narrative of how we arrived at where we are, but it goes much further.   It develops a theory that explains how it happened and how it works.  This has considerable practical value;  it is not simply of academic interest.   

The historical information alone is worth the time taken to read the book.  Did you know that Franklin Roosevelt vetoed the Uniform Revolver Act that was passed by the New York legislature in 1923, apparently favoring the more restrictive Sullivan act?

The meat of the book, however, is in the theory of how the gun culture created and developed the means to overcome the control of information flow by the ruling elite.   Brian Anse Patrick explicitly details how the gun culture that we know today was precipitated from the existing culture by attacks from the ruling elite; how opposition in the old media helped to grow and solidify it; how it came to form what he terms "horizontal interpretive communities".  

It is through the power of those overlapping communities that the gun culture is able to defeat attacks on the right to keep and bear arms, develop and pass legislation, defeat and elect politicians, and shape the national understanding of the Constitution. 

Here is what Professor Patrick has to say about the power of the NRA:

But NRA is not the source of the power.  The power lies in the matrix of horizontal associations that constitute the new gun culture.  NRA has money because these people provide money, lots of it, regularly.  They are not minions or "rank and file."  Emphatically, they do not serve the NRA; rather, NRA serves them as best it can.

I do not want to give the impression that Rise of the Anti-Media is about the NRA; it is not.   The NRA is covered, but is only a small part of the overall picture.

The focus of the book is on how concealed carry law was reformed across the country.   The book was published in 2010.   It anticipated the triumph of shall issue laws in Wisconsin and Illinois, but does not include them.   While the focus is on concealed carry laws, the theme applies to all the concerns of the gun culture.

If you want to understand the dynamics involved in restoring and creating a strong right to keep and bear arms across the United States, this book will provide answers.   I learned a great deal, and the book helped to solidify much of what I had surmised but did not have the available facts to verify.

The book does not provide a list of suggestions or actions on how to improve the existing strategies and tactics of the gun culture.   The theory of "horizontal interpretive communities" does, however, imply that some changes in emphasis could be useful.    It is left to the reader to determine how to use this new understanding to their advantage.

It is unfortunate that this important work has not received the attention that it deserves.   Much of that may be because it was only available from an academic press at a fairly high price.   The original hardcover sold for $70.   That edition is available on Amazon for $54.99.   The good news is that it is now available on Kindle for only $9.99.

Professor Patrick has informed me that a new edition is coming out in paperback this summer, published by Arktos.   It should retail for about $20.

 ©2014 by Dean Weingarten: Permission to share is granted when this notice is included.
Link to Gun Watch

[marktwain]

Freerepublic is a pretty good example of a "horizontal interpretive community". It is definitely part of the network of "horizontal media" that the author talks about, though he does not mention freerepublic explicitly.

[happyathome]

I think that “horizontal interpretive community” is a 21st century name for “committees of correspondence”.

[GeronL]

"horizontal interpretive community"

That sounds like something a leftist would have thought up

[marktwain]

“I think that “horizontal interpretive community” is a 21st century name for “committees of correspondence”.”

It is a good comparison.

Reading the book, there is no question where the author’s fits. He is one of us. I would not be surprised if he is a freeper.

[marktwain]

I should say “where the author’s sympathies fit”

[marktwain]

I was looking in my copy, and found this quote:

“The many state-level associations are like the Revolution’s state committees of correspondence.” Page 215, Rise of the Anti-Media

[publius911]

Bookmark

[elcid1970]

Or is the rise of the anti-media simply a product of the explosive growth of internet-enabled social nedia, websites, blogs, online `newspapers’ and other IT-based factors which traditional (meaning liberal) media is no longer able to control or ignore?

Ten years ago during the 2004 presidential campaign, “blog” was a new term.

Youtube.com has been in existence for less than a decade.

Texting for all it is misused is mass instant communication. Video uploads create instant news such as from the Middle East.

Talk radio is an established conservative bastion. Pathetic liberal imitations quickly wither & die.

In other words, the genie is out of the bottle & the MSM will never be able to put it back in.

Three network TV channels plus PBS? Gone with the wind!