zPlacemrk
Posted 01/05/12
Sunahara v. Hawaii Department of Health dismissed
Dean C. Haskins says I just received this message by email from Gerald Kurashima:
I just got out of the hearing. Unfortunately, the Judge ruled in favor of the State and effectively dismissed the Complaint.
The Judge treated this as a motion for summary judgment because the Judge considered matters outside the pleadings. However, the Judge did not give any reason or explanation for the ruling but just granted it in favor of the State.
We had a long discussion about HRS 338-13(a), and the Judge may have ruled that the statute provides for various forms of either a certified copy of a certificate, or contents, or any part thereof. The Court may have decided that the Director has the sole discretion as to the form of certificate it provides, but again there was no explanation given.
The State is going to prepare the Order then it will be filed. At that point there will be thirty (30) days to appeal the Judge’s decision.
We will be discussing these results with him to determine what he believes Duncan’s next step should be. Personally, I believe that this could be the result of the immense poisoning of vexatious and incompetent litigation that has plagued the Hawaiian court system, as this case should have been very easily won — if nothing but the law were considered.
What other motivation could a state have for denying someone a photocopy of his deceased sister’s original birth certificate? Of course, it couldn’t have anything to do with a different number appearing on Virginia’s original birth certificate. No, that would just be ridiculous birther talk.
Developing.
http://theobamafile.websitetoolbox.com/post/Bombshell!-The-Duncan-Sunahara-interview-5648949
What other motivation could a state have for denying someone a photocopy of his deceased sister’s original birth certificate? Of course, it couldn’t have anything to do with a different number appearing on Virginia’s original birth certificate. No, that would just be ridiculous birther talk.
It seems to me the reason they can't supply a copy of the original long form birth certificate for Virginia, is that THE CONTENT NO LONGER EXISTS, the content might have been removed and replaced with 'something else' and of the original, ONLY THE NUMBER REMAINS.