I find her attractive, too. And for 43, she looks fine to me! I think she’d do better trying to find interesting roles as a supporting character in independent films.
Yes, I think her days as a leading lady are numbered.
She did that in (an independent film that is) The Good Girl in 2002. It was a rather sad and dark film but I have to say that she carried off the role pretty well; she wasnt very likable and that was the point.
I also liked her in Marley & Me and of course in Office Space.