[RummyChick]

This just goes to show that no one ..and I mean NO ONE..knows how a ruling would come down from SCOTUS on this issue...despite FREEPERS who claim to know exactly what would happen.

Scalia does talk about it in the oral arguments of Nguyen.

[Lazamataz]

This just goes to show that no one ..and I mean NO ONE..knows how a ruling would come down from SCOTUS on this issue...despite FREEPERS who claim to know exactly what would happen.

After the Obamacare mandate ruling, it's as good as a coin toss. No part of the Constitution is meaningful, these days. I'm frankly amazed the Second Amendment got a win.

[DiogenesLamp]

This just goes to show that no one ..and I mean NO ONE..knows how a ruling would come down from SCOTUS on this issue...despite FREEPERS who claim to know exactly what would happen.

I have always assumed they would get it wrong. This just reinforces my belief that they would get it wrong. Unless someone has specifically researched this particular sub-topic of constitutional law, they DO NOT KNOW the truth. They are simply relying on left over conventional wisdom and misapplied precedent.