It does look very much like the same girl. What year is the French club photo supposed to be? They look younger in it then the one with the girls club. What year is it supposed to be? The girls club photo.
There’s no way of telling when ANY OF THE IMAGES were taken, the years attributed to them vary, no one has ever seen a FULL PAGE with a year-date on it. That’s WHY I’m going throught this exercise.
The group images are captioned Class of 1958, but there are several girls who graduated in 1960, so the group images have to be from Class of 1960.
It shouldn’t surprise anyone that it’s hard to follow, you have already noticed SHE isn’t there, so you could hardly expect the groups to be CAPTIONED Class of 1960, THAT WOULD GIVE THE GAME AWAY.
Take your time, there’s another sequence. I can show you but I cannot explain everything, we are dealing with some pretty tricky people, right?