Ummm, you didn’t answer my question. This sentence about the holding in Minor doesn’t help Chester Arthur, who would have been old news at the time of the WKA decision anyway. Let’s focus, chick. Why do both decision emphasize citizen parents??
Read the brief by the United States in Wong Kim ark
http://www.scribd.com/doc/23965360/Wong-Kim-Ark-US-v-169-US-649-1898-Appellants-Brief-USA
It is also helpful to find the lower court case.
I wonder if you will stop quoting Wong Kim Ark once you really see what went down.
Note that the person in question was deemed A NATURAL BORN CITIZEN.
Supreme Court affirmed the decision without exception.