>>Yes you repeatedly said gardening was useless, in fact you said repeatedly sait that planing for an economic collapse was useless.<<
You conflate 2 thoughts. Planning gardening is not the proper approach for a collapse. Gardening is a good idea.
Separate thoughts.
And if you disagree with the Mad Max scenario, I have never said it is the only possible scenario. I have merely said the entire world economy would need to collapse before “the collapse” would occur.
I have had a few people try to build scenarios, but they were narrow and the “proof” was individual and limited examples of civil disruptions. Or large-scale history that doesn’t seem to be evident.
And as I have said, I am arguing the points. I have called no one names and have not said anyone’s individual analysis was not thoughtful (although I have disagreed).
BS you repeated posted that the op was pushing a mad max senerio, I am the OP and I pointed out that in post number four I talked about a Argentina style collapse not a Mad Max world. I also posted a link to a doumentary on that collapse.
How so is gardening not a good in economic collapse, it saves money and provides food whats negitive? I can provide you first hand accounts from people in Argentina and Sarajevo both of which have references to gardening.
I sugest you spend some time reading http://ferfal.blogspot.com/
Survivng Argentina someone who is living through and in a collapse economy. You will find that everything we avocate he writes about. It happened and is happening there and it can happen here just as easy.
I repeated you are a punk kid that would set in the back of the class they had no interest in the class, they care not one wit if they pasted the class or not and they thought anyone that was interested in the class were fools, so what did they do, they interrupted and disturbed the class to a point in which it made it near impossible for anyone interested to learn.
And I again have to ask why would you other than an wanting to irritate people spend the evening posting on a subject you don’t believe in nor support?
What drives your need to be at the center of a discussion that not only you don’t believe in but can clearly add nothing positive to?