[DJ MacWoW]

Born in the USA = Natural born citizen.

So any Mexican kid born to two illegals can be President? I'm sure the Founders risked all they had and their very lives in order to hand it over to someone with divided loyalties. Use your head once in awhile.

There are records that show they used Vattel's Law of Nations when writing the Constitution so you lose.

Your argument would prevent a Jewish person from becoming President, tell that to the millions of jews in this country that none of them can become President.

What?! LOLOLOL!!! There are NO 2nd generation Jews in the US?! LOLOL!!!!

This is the first time I have ever registered at FreeRepublic.

Now WHERE have I heard THAT before?

[Darksheare]

“Your argument would prevent a Jewish person from becoming President, tell that to the millions of jews in this country that none of them can become President.”

Obviously he believes everyone here who is Semitic is first generation “sprung from the rocks” and none have come before.

He sounds like Gilbert Wilkes IV a.k.a. “casuist”.

[TNTNT]

You posted that an individual born with dual citizenship or dual loyalties cannot be NBC. All Jewish people born in the US are Isreali and US citizens at time of their birth. Thus my question, can a Jewish person be a NBC and elected President? The US has historically have not had any other country's laws be determinative of an individual’s citizenship status here in the USA. We fought a war (the war of 1812) over this very principle. I doubt if your or your birther buddies are going to get SCOTUS or the US Congress to change over 200 years of legal precedence.