One half of what could have been a great column...but then Peggy Noonan's Palin Derangement Syndrome had to kick in.Pity. Posted on 11/06/2010 2:08:42 PM PDT by hecht
Peggy Noonan Calls Sarah Palin A 'Nincompoop'
One half of what could have been a great column...but then Peggy Noonan's Palin Derangement Syndrome had to kick in.Pity.
Noonan's latest makes two cogent points - first that she's finally done with Obama:
On to the aftermath of the election. On Wednesday President Obama gave a news conference to share his thoughts. Viewers would have found it disappointing if there had been any viewers. The president is speaking, in effect, to an empty room. From my notes five minutes in: "This wet blanket, this occupier of the least interesting corner of the faculty lounge, this joy-free zone, this inert gas." By the end I was certain he will never produce a successful stimulus because he is a human depression.
Actually I thought the worst thing you can say about a president: that he won't even make a good former president. {...}
What Democrats have to learn from this election: Cut loose from that. Join with Republicans where you can, create legislation together, send the bill to the White House, see what happens. Even as the Republicans have succeeded in getting out from under George W. Bush, this is your chance to get out from under Mr. Obama, and possibly prosper in 2012 whatever happens to him.
The other cogent point Noonan makes is that the Tea Party Movement needs to realize both the message and the messenger is important, as she compares Marco Rubio with a Sharron Angle or a Christine O'Donnell. She has a point. But what she of course fails to get, like most ruling class elitists is that these people didn't nominate themselves. The voters did. And that even a well-spoken, gaffe free 'moderate' candidate can end up losing - ask Dino Rossi in Washington State about that.
At that point, Noonan's usual Palin Derangement Syndrome kicks in, sparked by Governor Palin's common sense answer to questions on FOX about her TV show about Alaska and 'Dancing With The Stars'..."Wasn't Ronald Reagan an actor? Wasn't he in 'Bedtime for Bonzo,' Bozo, something? Ronald Reagan was an actor."
Noonan's response was to say that Palin was ignorant and to go through Reagan's pre-Presidential resume, referring to his Hollywood profession as 'an artist'.
I have no doubt that the Gipper himself would have chuckled at that one, recalling all the lame movies he was compelled to make to earn that weekly paycheck, keep from angering the studio bosses and getting placed on suspension. And I doubt that President Reagan would have put hosting the GE Theater each week under the category of 'art'. Being a working actor didn't make him less of a great man, anymore than Palin sitting in the 'Dancing With The Stars' audience to root for her daughter diminished her. Noonan, of course, either missed that simple reality or chose to ignore it, as her PDS kicked in full strength:
The point is not "He was a great man and you are a nincompoop," though that is true. The point is that Reagan's career is a guide, not only for the tea party but for all in politics. He brought his fully mature, fully seasoned self into politics with him. He wasn't in search of a life when he ran for office, and he wasn't in search of fame; he'd already lived a life, he was already well known, he'd accomplished things in the world.
This 'nincompoop' as Noonan referred to her is directly responsible for GOP gains in this election. along with Jim DeMint. It was Palin in particular who kept the Tea Party movement within the Republican Party when she could have taken them third party for her own aggrandizement , and without the Tea Party things would be very different for the GOP today.
Governor Palin had the ninja political skills to go from being the defeated VP candidate in one of the most inept campaigns in recent memory to the hottest political ticket in America...and she did it on her own, outside the GOP establishment.
I and many others haven't forgotten how Peggy Noonan shilled for Obama during the '08 election and told us how wonderful he was going to be. Palin, on the other hand, had his number from Day One.
So who's the 'nincompoop', Peggy Noonan?
And that bit about accomplishment? Sarah Palin has been a mayor,a member of an important energy board in Alaska who took on the fat cats in her own party for corruption and won, a governor who took on Big oil, balanced Alaska's budget and put through a vital energy pipeline that had been sitting in limbo for thirty years, a successful small business owner, a vice presidential candidate, and she's now a best selling author, speaker, political voice and TV commentator whose fans mob her wherever she goes. And she's still in her forties.
And what was it Peggy Noonan accomplished again? A few speeches written a quarter of a century ago, a couple of books, writing a weekly column and attending a few of the right Manhattan cocktail parties.Oh, yes, and lying to her readers.
Whatever else she's done, Sarah Palin has made a difference, a positive change in America's political climate. Peggy Noonan never will, and that probably fuels her rage as much as anything.
Absolutely right.
This is just a thinly veiled "the Conservatives need to compromise" article full of typical noonancompoop puffery.
Peggy Noonan. What a Behar.
Anyone who liked Obama in 2008 has lost my respect, including Ms. Noonan. Logic and reason have departed from her environment. And throw in Kathleen Parker into that dustbin also.
Noonan? Whose heart was all a-flutter, with lovey-dovey enchantment over Barack a few short months ago?
She’s an elitist POS. No surprise she hates Palin. Peggy, just grab one of your Manhattan cocktails and proceed to Hell where you belong.
Someone get the hook for this old hag.
No, a “nincompoop” is ANYONE who thought that a guy with NO real-world experience who attended an antiWhite/antiAmerican/antiSemitic church for 20 years “might” make a good President...
Anyone that supported 0baMao for even a minute has no room to call anyone a nincompoop. That’s like questioning your parent’s driving skills after causing a fatal accident in a carnival bumper car.
GMTA! I immediately thought of Norma Desmond and Sunset Strip when I read the title of this thread.
Noonan supported Obama. So who is the biggest nicompoop now, Peggy?
Peggy Noonan is an arrogant, elitist, inside the beltway TWIT.
Please, please, please! Ms Noonan was in her day a great speechwriter, she did more for Reagan than Reagan’s idiot staff or kids did. Too bad she has fallen and can’t get up. This is this first time I have any sympathy for anyone in the political arena. It’s really unfortunate that she expressed herself in this way. Please be kind to her. Let us remember her as a National Treasure.
Noonan is a snob and I’m no fan of hers, but I do think Palin would get crushed in the general if she got the GOP nomination in 2012.
GREAT ARTICLE. Shows who the real nincompoop is.
Wow, what a harpy woman! Lighten up Peg, remember this: “My fellow Americans, I’m pleased to tell you today that I’ve signed legislation...that will outlaw Russia forever. We begin bombing in 5 minutes.”
Spoken by a great man with a wonderful sense of humor. That was an endearing part of his personality.
Must everything be serious? Why rip on Sarah this way?
ML/NJ
Peggie Noonan needed Ronald Reagan. As long as she transmitted his vision in inspired prose, she was the best of the best. But Ronald Reagan did not need Peggie Noonan. Her once lofty writing style now serves a second rate intellect—her own.
I was amazed at Noonan calling Reagan “an artist.” What poppycock - to use a Noonan word along with “ninconpoop” and “pshaw.” Reagan was many, many things but he was NOT an artist. He was a good, solid working film actor and a political genuis. Peggy is a tired old broad with a really stale act.
Plus she’s a dead ringer for Murkowski. yeeech.
Peggy Noonan got how many Republicans elected in the midterms?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.