[Mr. Silverback]

[SNICKER] Yeah, he self-identifies as a gay pagan Unitarian, but he could still be an ethnic Jew! Oh man, the Ministry of Silly Explanations never fails to disappoint.

[George W. Bush]

Yeah, he self-identifies as a gay pagan Unitarian, but he could still be an ethnic Jew!

Plenty of Jewish people are atheist or non-devout. No one questions whether they're Jewish. I always think of them as ethnically Jewish. If a Gentile converts to Judaism, then they are Jewish only for religious reasons.

So the question I raised is perfectly reasonable. But thanks for trolling anyway.