I have asked the very simple question (when my license and registration is demanded to be turned over), what probable cause do you have? Why did you pull me over?
I have never had the question answered, but I have been threatened as this kid was.
Doubters are welcome to try it on your own. Not with me in the car, please, even as cameraman.
Here in TX, I don’t think I’ve ever had that question go unanswered. In fact, usually the cop comes right out and tells you what he pulled you over for, even before asking for my paperwork.
This is usually what happens when I’m pulled over:
Officer: “Good evening, sir. How’re you doing?”
Me: “Not bad, officer. How may I help you?”
Officer: “The reason I pulled you over is because I clocked you going 75 in a 60. May I have your license and proof of insurance, please?”
Alternately:
Officer: “Good evening, sir. May I see your license and proof of insurance, please?”
Me: “Here you go, officer.”
Officer: “The reason I pulled you over is because I clocked you going 75 in a 60. Stay here while I go run these, please.”
This is how it is supposed to go.
Cop: Good morning. You were going 75 in a 60. May I see your driver’s license, and registration please.
Driver: Oh. Hands over requested items.
Cop: Thanks. Do you have current insurance?
Driver: Yes, no. Whatever.
Cop: Any reason why you were speeding?
Driver: Admits, excuses, denial.
Cop: I’ll be back in a few minutes.
Naturally, there are minor variations, but I never argued or debated. You should always be told what violation the cop thought you did before you are asked for any ID. That is polite and professional and takes a couple of seconds.