Free Republic
Browse · Search
Smoky Backroom
Topics · Post Article

To: Accygirl; JenB; SuziQ; Bear_in_RoseBear; Rose in RoseBear
I don’t see why the death of the main character is all that awful that an eleven/ twelve year old couldn’t stomach it...

It has nothing to do with the intensity of the books. But with a perceived "relationship" many young readers have with Harry.

Devastating adults, or college age students who started reading HP in grade school (my son among them) is one thing.

Devastating a 7-year-old is entirely a different matter.

It's just my theory. Your mileage may vary.

262 posted on 07/22/2007 8:14:05 PM PDT by Corin Stormhands (I drink coffee for your protection.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 254 | View Replies ]


To: Corin Stormhands
Seven year olds really shouldn’t be reading Deathly Hallows!! My mother would most definitely not let me read The Deathly Hallows @ age seven just like she wouldn’t let me see a PG-13 or R rated movie. I’d be reading Ramona, Charlotte’s Web, or the Little House books and that would be that...

BTW, there’s lots of movies and books geared to young elementary children that deal quite frankly with death (Charlotte’s Web, my fav. book in second grade for one) or Bambi or Old Yeller.

264 posted on 07/22/2007 8:22:30 PM PDT by Accygirl
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 262 | View Replies ]

To: Corin Stormhands
It's a kid's fairy tale. Not finishing up with "... and they all lived happily ever after!" would just be wrong.

IMHO, YMMV, OMGWTFBBQ.

265 posted on 07/22/2007 8:22:57 PM PDT by Bear_in_RoseBear (Loot it while it lasts)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 262 | View Replies ]

To: Corin Stormhands

On the deeper level it’s the difference between the series being a morality play and a tragedy. In a morality play the main character learns and grows and screws up and learns some more and suffers and learns but in the end triumphs over evil thanks to what he learned. In a tragedy you do everything possible to make the readers love the main character then you kill him, often times pointlessly. If Harry dies in the end, especially if he dies without striking down Voldemort, the whole thing becomes a tragedy, and the moral lessons become somewhat weakened (what’s really the point of all that learning and growing just to bye the farm).

Tragedies tend to be less popular because we like our heroes to triumph, and there is a certain cruelty in spending hundreds of pages making people love a character just to whack him. It would have been kind of funny after 10 years of selling vast forests of books to turn the whole series into shaggiest dog of a tragedy ever, probably would have made some of the literary nerds like the series better. But I think it probably would have irritated a lot of the audience.


271 posted on 07/22/2007 8:41:49 PM PDT by discostu (indecision may or may not be my biggest problem)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 262 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Smoky Backroom
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson