[silent_jonny]

Out of all of them, Taylor and Chris are real...I haven't seen enough of Katharine or Elliot to know.

IMO, they're all real. This is the most talented final four (and final five) that Idol has ever had. That doesn't mean they're always perfect--McPhee was terrible last week and Chris nearly screamed his voice away--but they all have genuinely good voices.

[twin2]

Whoo hoo! Three threads this year!

Do I get any risiduals for using my clever quote?

[sirchtruth]

Yeah, they can all sing...What I mean is paid music dues, been there done that, worked very hard, sincerely understands the soul of music.

Come'on you've got to admit Taylor is not going to be some "IDOL" star, especially if he truly gets back to what he's really all about. He's a musicians, musician, to really show his talent, Taylor has got to make the most of what's in him, not what AI wants to make of him.

It really doesn't matter, they're all basically "Idols" now...These four have made if they want it.

BTW, Great pics, thanks!