American Idol 2006--Live Thread (Part III)

Fox ^ | 5-8-06

[silent_jonny]

always for Tammy

[PayNoAttentionManBehindCurtain]

Omagosh!!! Wasn't Taylor's "You are so Beautiful" just incredible. Best song of the whole competition.

Katherine sucked all night, IMO.

And Elliot, other then the first song, just seems like he's given up. I was hoping for so much better from him.

Becky

[conservativebabe]

I've only gotten through 3 times and I've been hitting redial nonstop.

[LA Woman3]

Tonight's performances......(sorry if already posted!)

http://www.idol-thoughts.com/My_Homepage_Files/Page42.html

[I'm ALL Right!]

I'm still praying for (and voting for ) an Elliot/Taylor finale.

[Conservative Texan Mom]

Given the erratic nature of Kat's voice, I bet she would be a good yodeler.

[Palladin]

>>>So, is the consensus that it's going to be a Tay Tay/Ta Ta finale?<<<

Sure looks like it from where I'm sitting.

Taylor was great on all three songs.

Elliott excelled on his first number only.

Kat was great on OTR... the other two songs were so-so. But she gets the male vote.

So, yes, I am calling a Tay-Tay vs. Ta-Ta grand finale.

[merry10]

I don't want Kat to win - I am probably jealous. I admit it. But I thought Over the Rainbow was wonderfully done although I don't get her sitting on the floor thing.

You will LOVE Taylor!

[mystery-ak]

post Taylor's number so I can try...I have speed dial..

[del4hope]

We still haven't gotten through to Elliot or Taylor (we are voting for both of them).

I am out of here.

[silent_jonny]

Dont you think Kat would look cute with short hair. I think it is too long.

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

[BamaDi]

and if he wins - all five winners will be Southerners....if you count OK as a southern state....but hey, Carrie sings country!

[OldFriend]

Taylor hits the songs into our souls.

He has something that makes you want to smile when he sings.

[Jrabbit]

I love you for giving this link every week! awwww...Taylor....

[retrokitten]

LOL!!!

[BamaDi]

Amen to that.....Taylor improved with each song tonight - hitting a home run on #2 and #3....

[retrokitten]

He sure does. You Are So Beautiful made me tear up.

[A knight without armor]

Yes! I'm so glad Simon said something so nice to Taylor. I can't wait to turn off the computer and begin my cell phone call button pushing marathon for Taylor!!!!!!!!!!

I must say Elliot's mother looks so precious. She really is so proud. I hate for her that Elliot will leave. Surely Elliot has been discovered now and will go on to great opportunities. I know he has and will do her proud always.

Did you notice the "Where's Chris?" sign in the audience? There was another one about Chris also.

[silent_jonny]

when Simon said that Kat's performance was the BEST of the COMPETITION??

He might have said "her" best of the competition, I wasn't sure.

[Sea2ShiningSea]

My absolute favorite comedy! I have watched it at least a gazillion times!!!!!!!

Your going the wrong way!!!!!!!!!

[Palladin]

Taylor got spazzy and over-the-top on the last "ten....der...neeaaaeeeesss." I thought he was going to stroke out, and that Paula would have to rush on stage to give him mouth-to-mouth resuscitation.