Yeah, what does this do to the gardner's statement. Is there another car that looks like Deepak's on the island? What 3 people did the gardner see?
Wasn't the pond where the gardner said he saw them at just north of the hotels? If both the 2:40 and 3:00 calls came from the area just north of the hotels, wouldn't it show Juran didn't walk home, but was still in that area?