Could be the body was recovered (if it was) not exactly in the middle - maybe a little off-center - more toward the edge. Maybe the outer parts were dry that night, but the middle was still wet, thus the conflicting reports of whether the area was wet/dry that night.
Bookmark for later!
I have not heard or read any other news outlet reporting that a body has been found. Not even on the Aruban forums that I have checked.