The amount the government takes, IMO, is less important than what the government spends. What good did it do to get a tax break when spending increased massively? Sooner or later, that needs to be paid for, either by me or by future generations.
Bush has had four primary failings:
1 - increased federal government involvement in education
2 - failure to increase border security or deal with illegal immigration
3 - runaway spending
4 - the Medicare prescription drug benefit, which made our entitlement crisis worse, not better.
Those are not trivial matters. And he needs to hear that he was wrong - especially on #2, which is a serious threat to our safety and a failure to carry out his proper, constitutional duties. The other three are usurpations of federal power - but borders are a fundamental federal responsibility.
Precisely why Dr. Walter Williams has advocated a constitutional SPENDING CAP as expressed by percentage of GNP.
You forgot the Farm Bill, CFR, endorsing civil "unions" and a host of other things.
Only thing he's done right is the WOT.
Good post, and right on target.