[Mamzelle]

re: And it would explain all the weird Arwen stuff in TTT.)))

I thought the discussion between Elrond and Arwen in TTT to be very effective movie storytelling--particularly that wonderful scene from the appendix about her own mortality should she choose to stay in Middle Earth.

If PJ wants to be very nice to his fans, he could film a "appendix documentary" for the extended version of ROTK to include the beginning of the Fourth Age of Middle Earth, and Sam's career as mayor of Hobbiton...the stuff that's in the appendix. With a voiceover narrative, wouldn't be too much trouble...(g)p>

[ElfArcher]

I liked the Arwen and Elrond scene in TTT. What was weird is how she walks off at the end of it, it isn't explained, and one is left to assume that she is going to the Grey Havens.

There will be a TTTEE scene, where Elrond and Arwen are talking about something else, and Arwen possibly goes to lorien instead. There is no evedence either way.

If PJ bes nice to us we be nice to him, Yes precious, we promises not to throw anythings nasty at him. :D