Replies

Hello, just found this area and feel a need to ask some questions on the smart case. 1- has Ed Smart account for his sleeping time that night? (like ricci had to). 2- why did ed have to call his brother first? 3- Why were the girls sleeping in the same bed? --what are they so scared of?-- 4-Why did mk wait so long to tell parents? 5- Its stated that the parents were getting a divorce, where they sharing the same room? have they been fighting? 6- Has Tom Smart accounted for his time? was he home when he was called or did ed call him on a cell phone? Mark my words Im not trying to make it sound that the smarts are involved but it seems that journal reporting is also one sided. Other families of missing children are run through the ringer but not the smarts, I know they are very involved in donating money and getting what they want from the city but it seems to me cnn isnt bought from the smarts so why are they asking such questions or other jounalist??? This is a bad thing which I wish would be solved the right way there are to many girls sleeping with their mommies these days including mine. Im from utah and have done some searching for Eliz and the right questions are not being ask and really really need to be aired so one man will be standing alone. At some point I really would like to air(state) what I know but to scared right know. please see brigettes http://pub37.ezboard.com/belizabethsmartcaseforum
Im waiting for a reply there as well.

1- has Ed Smart account for his sleeping time that night? (like ricci had to).
Ed Smart underwent a polygraph test. I do not know the questions, but that question could (and should) have been one of them.

2- why did ed have to call his brother first?
The Smarts have maintained that they called the SLPD first (911). The SLPD has said that the questions as to who was called first has been answered to their satisfaction. I know many posters here (including me) would like to see the phone records from that night.

3- Why were the girls sleeping in the same bed? --what are they so scared of?
The girls shared a room because their mother Lois had shared a room growing up with her sisters, and remembered the many happy times they had together. She wanted her own daughters to experience the same thing and grow close. I don't think the girls were scared of anything by sleeping in the same bed.

4-Why did mk wait so long to tell parents?
The police have stated that the abductor threatened Elizabeth's life if she made a sound. The SLPD won't release the perp's exact words, but Mary Katherine did get up to tell her parents immediately after the perp and Elizabeth left the bedroom. She then saw them in another part of the house, got scared because of the threats made to her sister, and went back to her bedroom to wait until she thought it was safe. The layout of the Smart home on the 2nd floor has the girls' room, the stairs, and then the master bedroom. I think the perp and Elizabeth were by the stairs (my theory, not an official one), and Mary Katherine would have had to walk directly by them to get to her parents' bedroom.

5- Its stated that the parents were getting a divorce, where they sharing the same room? have they been fighting?
That is hearsay, that the Smarts were getting a divorce. The only place I've heard that rumor is on the boards on the Interent from alleged neighbors. I have heard the Smarts talk about their bedroom, how the kids would sleep in their bedroom with them, so I assume they are still sharing a bedroom. Again, my assumption.

6- Has Tom Smart accounted for his time? was he home when he was called or did ed call him on a cell phone?
Tom Smart has also had a polygraph, his was inconclusive. I heard a polygraph expert say that an inconclusive polygraph means that it is as if the person never took the polygraph, the police cannot ascertain if the person is telling the truth or not, and so it is considered inconclusive. Also, that innocent people have inconclusive polygraphs, as do guilty ones. Again, I'd like to see the phone records, cellphone records are very traceable, and I am sure the police have combed those. And Heidi Smart, Tom's wife, has said that Tom was in bed with her all that night.

I"m from Utah (obviously), but I think there is a lot of information that we are not getting, much information that has been misreported by the press, and a lot of misinformation put out by the SLPD to trip up the abductor. I know my nieces especially are scared, and are very careful.