[Overtaxed]

I was wondering if his innocence came from the fact that he is the Eldest...that he came to Middle Earth "before the Dark Lord came from the Outside."

[ksen]

I was wondering if his innocence came from the fact that he is the Eldest...that he came to Middle Earth "before the Dark Lord came from the Outside."

But is he really the eldest? I thought that Treebeard was called the oldest thing in Middle-Earth? I am so confused.

If this branch of discussion is not appropriate here, dealing with Treebeard and all, I am willing to continue on the Hobbit Hole thread.

-ksen