Worried in what way about Gondor and Rohan?
What more is he supposed to say for them?
and how exactly is he more worried about Rivendell than anyone else?
I propose that he didn't say he wanted to protect Rivendell, only that Rivendell could not withstand both Mordor and Isenguard... So the ring could not "stay" there. Another option needed to be found!
What is with the boy's choir track on this CD? - it scared me, coming in out of the blue like that!
All his dialogue is about Rivendell. All his talk is about what would happen if Rivendell fell. Wouldn't it be worse for ME as a whole if Gondor and Rohan fell? "Rivendell cannot withstand both Mordor and Isengard." Well what makes him think that Gondor and Rohan can? They're on the front lines already fighting the battle while he's in the rear whining about what will happen to Rivendell when all the Elves are leaving it anyway.
He ought to be more worried about Gondor and Rohan. If the Enemy is stopped there then his precious Rivendell would be safe.
It's not the logic that I have the problem with...it's the attitude!