He was THE least believable Fletcher Christian and Mark Anthony EVER to say those lines!
Was he good as other characters? Yes, but had a really limited range.
I had heard that he had issues as Mark Antony, but I do consider Stanley Kowalski to be very different from Vito Corleone. I didn’t see him as Fletcher Christian. Now that you mention it, he was badly miscast in “Guys and Dolls” as well.
Agree with you! That guy is the #1 most overrated actor, ever!