I drink Flor de Cana 12 year regularly, but I like Zacapa 23 more than that, just can’t afford it. I would have to say Z23 is my favorite everyday rum.
I was entry level with Appleton 20+ years ago, and it was truly my gateway. I have tried many many rums, and my favorites are almost always somewhere in the Caribbean and just beyond.
I’m totally a pirate in this regard.
My cousin is a big Captain fan