[plsvn]

Sorry...

Sherman said the plural of moose was meese because the plural of mouse was mice. I guess these things were important back then.

[dfwgator]

Sherman said the plural of moose was meese

"I resemble that remark!"

(Still with us, at 92)

[SamuraiScot]

I guess these things were important back then.

Personally, I would go for the lower-hanging precedent:

The plural of "goose" is geese, hence the plural of "moose" clearly would be meese.

QED.