[Arcadian Empire]

The elves look foppish and effete.

The hobbits look like the horribly-mistreated and cast-adrift unloved cousins of the hobbits who lived in Bilbo’s Shire.

[1ScrappyArmyMom]

They are already declaring Elrond gay now, despite him being married with 3 kids.

[Telepathic Intruder]

Yeah, the elves don't look or act like elves, and the hobbits don't look or act like hobbits.

All the elves have the same barber by the look of it. They are not supposed to have short-cropped poofy salon-style haircuts.

And the hobbits (harfoots are hobbits, btw) are all wearing rags and covered in dirt. They are supposed to be English-cultured and mannered, like Tolkien intended.

At least the dwarves sort of look like dwarves. I don't think the Scottish accents are accurate, though.