I buy mine from Costco also but it is Skippy creamy. Do they have Jif also?
At ours they do, but I live in the Cincinnati area, HQ of P&G, non P&G stuff sells poorly.
I returned my remaining jar and Costco refunded the whole price of the two pack I had bought. They only had some expensive organic stuff to replace it, so I just stopped at a Kroger and bought a jar of the store brand to tide us over.