Yes, but somehow, it’s in the script, so I’m not going to argue. It’s a cameo appearance and that could mean anything. Also, his “love-hate” interest is coming back in the same episode. So is her “mother.” I think not permanently for either woman.
I guess the lesson here is that if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. The commissioner’s over-the-top niece is leaving with the new sergeant in the last episode of Season 9, so that should improve the humor aspect. Sergeant Florence Cassell is coming back, evidently on a permanent basis but JP Hooper is leaving at the end of episode 8, season 9.
I think the amusement value dropped because there was no actual chemistry between the actors. In a series like this, that chemistry is vital to keep the interest of the viewers.
Excellent point. I like Florence, but losing J.P. is disappointing. He’s a sweet young man.