[Steve_Seattle]

The only one I might agree on is "God Only Knows." I absolutely can't stand "Bohemian Rhapsody," and "Whole Lotta Love" is almost as bad. I really like "Gimme Shelter," but the highlight of that song is the guitar work, not the vocal.

The fact that Roy Orbison and Bonnie Raitt are missing is not a good sign.

[Dave W]

I don’t consider them rock...sorry. I like both, though.

[DLfromthedesert]

Robert Plante’s voice is beyond annoying.

[knarf]

I considered it all a waste of time .... Van Halen just has a fantastic voice so he could sing do re mi and it would be awesome

[nicollo]

I really like "Gimme Shelter," but the highlight of that song is the guitar work, not the vocal.

Actually, Gimme Shelter is a perfect example of how a great song is larger than the parts. Check out the isolated tracks here:

DECONSTRUCTING ‘GIMME SHELTER’: LISTEN TO THE ISOLATED TRACKS OF THE ROLLING STONES IN THE STUDIO