So sadly true...Why we see so many savable structures turned into parking lots these days because aggressive interior attack firefighting tactics are being replaced by the “surround and drown” approach...
The extremely risk averse careerist mentality, guided by bean counters and attorneys, afraid of their own shadows where career advancement repercussion fears prevail, are now running the show...
“The Courage To Act” was one of our big three when I was “on the job”, and failure to act to save a life was considered dereliction of duty...A firefighter dedicates himself to the lives of other first...Othersise it’s just another job, like trash collection...Apparently, in some places no longer...Another tradition falls to “rules”...I was taught “rules are for fools”...A firefighter thinks for himself and acts!
At least, the good Captain followed his conscience, and did what he knew was right...He may pay a price now, but the reward comes later, and from his peers in his reputation...I’d be proud to back him up on a handline anytime!
Aggressive interior attack can mean opening doors wnd windows, and letting in oxygen, which can cause a very rapid ignition.
Fire science has come a very long way. Current tactics are based on the latest knowledge and focuses on firefighter safety, and effective use of resources.
Saving life is a first priority, but very few people survive a fully involved structure fire. If you’ve ever seen one up close and personal, you know what I mean. No amount of protective gear will save you from that kind of heat, so even if you tried to enter, you just won’t be able.
We have watch ed a lot of videos in training where a fire was over vented and the building virtuallt exploded in flame.
Current fire science says get to the actual flames and put as much water on it as you can. Avoid over venting, be selective and act smart. We’re volunteers, we don’t take any oath that says we must risk our lives, but what we do say is risk a little to save a little, risk a lot to save a lot.
It could be this captain was the only one in bunker gear near enough the building who could get in in time. It was a judgement not to wait, which could cause a delay. Sad that it didn’t work out for him, but i don’t blame him for trying. I think a reprimand would have been more appropriate than suspension.
I do not want a single firefighter to die trying to save my “structure” or my possessions. Save a life, sure. But buildings can be rebuilt. I have insurance. It would be crazy for someone to get themselves killed rescuing my ottoman.