What you are claiming was pretty much a correct assessment in say, the 1960s.
No it based on reality that the IT posse simply refuses to learn. Your sort of IT bot have been preaching the same nonsense since the 1970s and it always just around the corner, never here.
You cannot make the computer do deductive reasoning. It always limited to it programming. I work with current generation tech and it far short of the wonder the IT bots sold to Management. “why can we not do this” and it because the computer cannot think outside it programming. The person can.
This article outlines how cutting edge IT tech is being baffled by simply human cheating. Did you READ the article? It proves the point I am making.
Tech is not smart enough to recognize the flaw and adapt. Humans do almost without conscious thought