I found this article amazing. Here was a “scholar” reviewer who apparently had never heard of a NYTimes #1 bestseller that is now in its 30th printing; is used in “Classical Conversations”; is in use in 40 colleges and universities; and which is the #1 conservative “textbook” used by homeschoolers everywhere.
Moreover, it was reviewed (favorably) when it came out by the . . . Wall Street Journal.
PHUSA now has sold over 350,000 copies, with half a million copies in print, and will appear in its 4th edition this July (the “Fifteenth Anniversary Edition”).
What, you expect journalist/scholars to be well-informed on their subject matter? How unreasonable!