Disinformation is real.Could be similar to Trump tweeting, about Comey, "He better hope there aren't tapes."
Disinformation is necessary.
You've been around long enough to know it is prudent to take pretty much everything with some amount of skepticism. How and where and how much of it to apply is challenging.
Anyway, if we accept that Q deliberately plants falsehood, what you propose as a "reality-based scorecard" will show a number of failures. So would a reality-based scorecard of Trump tweets.
CTH isn't perfect either. I find numerous connection of dots created through speculation, when an alternative fact-based explanation gets to the same point.
-- I find the claim that Mueller is really helping Trump laughable. And, correct me if I'm wrong, wasn't that the whole original theme of Q-anon, fleshed out in dozens of haikus? --
Q never claimed Mueller was going after Hillary, or similar, if that's what you mean by helping Trump. An argument can be made that camp Mueller was like a flame is to moths, and that part was helpful - and painful at the same time. Q has mostly posed questions about Mueller, and admitted the totality was confusing. People can swing either way on Mueller, eg, LS here (Larry Schweikart) was a proponent of "Mueller is going after the FBI and Hillary" theory for awhile, maybe still is. Others, myself included, say "no way." I think Q would laugh and say "keep puzzling!"
NEW- Treasury inspector general launches probe into possible leak of Michael Cohen’s banking records
cc: @MichaelAvenatti https://t.co/y3tUgNWTkY— Falco (@Nick_Falco) May 9, 2018