This is to replace a dying Toshiba Satellite L305D.
I am only replacing it because a cap on the motherboard has popped, and it is S_L_O_W to boot, and shuts down when trying to update or load programs other than Brave or IE. Edge even shuts it down.
I have saved most of my important data, and will migrate to the new box when I get it.
The thing is, the computers you listed are all so old that I would expect them to have various problems: e.g., hard drives near failure, batteries at end of service life, etc. The Mac you listed would be something like $50 used. What is your budget?