Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

To: silent_jonny
Caleb stole the show for me and Mrs. Commish last night. His rendition of "When Doves Cry" was an instant Idol Classic. Just flat out Amazing.

Our Rankings last night:
1. Caleb - may have just made himself the front runner.
2. Maddie - Consistent week in and week out.
3. Cade - What can I say, we love the rockers.
4. Michael - Kid just blew it out on his second song.
5. Gabby - Lowest we have had her rated.
6. Jurnee - has actually gron on us the last couple weeks, but first song this week was awful, second song great.
7. Catie - Channeling Simon, "Sorry you forget the lyrics you are done. bye bye now".

I think next week is completely wide open. Caleb has come on strong the past couple weeks, Gabby, Maddie and Michael are all so consistently good, and when Cade hits it with a song he is amazing (but he is also the one most prone to flop too).

3,299 posted on 05/07/2018 10:35:09 AM PDT by commish (Freedom tastes Sweetest to those who have fought to preserve it!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3255 | View Replies ]


To: commish

my prior predictions... Know we were pretty much in agreement then...

Top 5 in no special order

Cade
Maddie
Michael
Gabby
Catie

Top 3

Gabby
Michael
Cade

Top 2

Michael.... ( gets the advantage of split votes between cade and gabby)

Gabby

Winner

Michael.......... new, different , very likable......

We shall see....


wrong on Catie....


Agree on Calebs rendition of When Doves Cry.... An instant winner in terms of presentation, originality, and certainly pulled in the country, and probably other votes...

New prediction..

Maddie, Michael, Gabby for top 3

Cade loses out, I think he lost a lot of ground this week. Do agree when he is on he is quite the entertainer, but last night , at least to me, proved stay safe, highlight your voice, and less is better.

Gabby, Maddie, and certainly Cade all did that.

Michael was great on second song, but first one was so different for him, and to my old ears, harder to follow.


No charge commentary :):):)

These judges are the worst..... Same old cliches..... no real critique... I think they know they are neutered by the new format, and blew it with their saves and “ america got it wrong “ play...


3,302 posted on 05/07/2018 2:11:53 PM PDT by patriotspride
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3299 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson