His dates are wrong, of course, but might well be the view of the time, given the width and depth of his own reading. It's interesting, to me, to see the 1792 New York Dutch view of the essence of the Columbus debate we're reading about today.
My family settled in “New Netherlands” in 1661, been here ever since.
bkmk
Just was reading this last night in the marvelous Henry Livingston bio. What a delightful read. There can be no doubt of the authorship of tnbc. His wit and charm just leap! off the page!