If the Halal tradition is anything like the Kosher tradition, the fact that the restaurant in question even STORED non-Halal meat makes it non-Halal, IMHO.
Correct.
A couple of points:
Under Jewish cultural laws, if you accidentally eat traif, you are not committing a sin.
The fact is that Little Caesars DOES serve pork products, so it is literally impossible that this guy wouldn't be exposed to "unclean" meat.
They don't sterilize the pizza cutter between orders, so those evil juices are going to be on his pizza.
The previous orderer could have ordered a meat lovers, cut with the SAME knife.
And YES, I've heard of Muslims demanding that the pizza knife be washed in front of them just to be sure.
It reminds me of the Hindu guy who ordered a bean burrito at a Taco Bell and got a beef burrito by mistake, then demanded that his WHOLE family get a free trip to India to "cleanse himself"
I worked at Taco Bell, and let me assure you that there is NO WAY that a bean burrito won't have some ground beef attached to the scoops and spoons.
If this Muslim is *that* strict, he had no reason to be in a frickin' pizza parlor in the first place.
Does he have no concept of what pizza even means?