You insult G-d by inferring that He has limitations on His love and caring and must parcel it out to the most deserving? What blasphemy!
You insult every human with a heart who loves their cherished pet. Many FReepers have cherished pets that they adore. When their pet suffers, they suffer right along with it. Been there myself, know how agonizing it feels to watch your pet suffer from an illness and feel helpless to alleviate its suffering. I have tears in my eyes right now, putting myself where Yaelle and her kitty must be right now.
Animals indeed are a blessing and a concern of God, and both Jewish and Christian scripture backs up the idea.
Say a prayer for the children starving in India, if it burdens your heart. Nobody says you shouldn’t.