The first Jay (John Traynor) left (foolishly) after their 1st hit “She Cried”.
I was young (preteen) when the Cara Mia became popular but have always loved it...it pulls at me emotionally.
I did not realize until the first Jay’s (Traynor) death in 2o14 that two Jays were associated with the group. It was at the time, I researched the group and purchased their CDs (with Jay Black) of which I love listening while driving.