[Nifster]

Have no idea what you think constitutes good quarter backing....he was meh at best

[nickcarraway]

Do you expect a new QB to come into the league playing like an experienced QB? And you have to grade it on a curve, considering the organization he was playing for. I think he played well enough to show he should get to keep playing.

There aren't enough good QBs for every team in the league. And it's worse when bad teams destroy QBs that would otherwise be good.

[equaviator]

1957- Detroit Lions w/Bobby Layne at QB. The last time Detroit won it all. If you don't remember who Bobby Layne was or what he was like off the field... From Wikipedia: "He would drink six days a week and play football on Sunday"; but his heavy drinking may have contributed to his death. Layne is reported to have stated: "If I'd known I was gonna live this long, I'd have taken a lot better care of myself."