That might be something that could work.
I just don’t see the use in giving the ability to retain judges to the public.
One simply has to look at the senate, and congress too for that matter, to see that’s a non-starter.
Ideally the senate would be back under the control of the state legislatures.
I like the idea of allowing state legislatures to vote. The general public does not take the necessary time to get informed and are too easily manipulated.