“This student feels it is obvious that ID has the upper hand in the argument - - - the ID proponent generally wins hands down.”
One may have the upper hand in an argument and win hands down with a logically thinking open minded person that will comprehend the facts and evidence.
But with regards to trying to convince a liberal, the above statements are 100% pure fantasy and fairy tales. You will never win an argument with a loud mouthed emotionalistic brainwashed lib.
The hallmark of liberal minds is Magic Thinking ... ‘accidents happen’ is their fallback position on anything which reason exposes as their false premise.