[dr_lew]

Your suggested argument is not based on physical reasoning, it is purely rhetorical and suggestive.

1. immaterial

2. no objective physical meaning - a rhetorical premise.

3. given to suggest a syllogism

4. redundant with 1.

5. subjective, and immaterial.

Study question: assumes the rhetorical premise - a mere trick.

[abclily]

My argument is solid logic. You are not familiar with the transitive property?