Clark Beckham
Clark is getting a little big for his britches. He picks a terrible song and neither Borchetta or 1/3 Rascal Flatts can convince him otherwise.
He sings it anyway. It's that song Scotty McCreery sang all the time when he was on the show. "Baby, lock the door, turn the lights down" something. You would hear this song as you're about to have a wisdom tooth removed.
Jlo : Some controversy. You sang it well, that's not the question. But you're on American Idol. Is this your gravy song? Your earlier songs blew us away and this didn't do it. You have to think of that.
Harry : IT boils down to hyper-specific song choice. You have to think about the audience more than yourself. It was kinda tepid, man. You have to knock it out of the park.
Keith : You don't need album tracks (filler) you need hits.
Clark spends several minutes trying to convince us (maybe himself) that this bland dentist office muzak really is his gravy.