Tyree’s catch was virtually impossible to make, and Eli was almost down when me made the throw.
Well Tyree’s catch was certainly a more significant catch in the big scheme of things.
You can’t add what the QB was doing when you’re rating “the catch.”
Everyone who is judging purely the catch - not the situation, not the magnitude of the game, not whether they won or lost - is unanimous that this is the greatest catch. Pure catch. Period.
Everyone who wants to add in situation, who won, etc, is not. I think we’re either talking about a catch, or not. I think there’s a difference between the most important catch and the best pure catch. Tyree’s was more important. This one was more freakishly great.