I agree with you, but whenever I say that, I am told that women cannot fairly judge other women.....whatever.
What makes Scarlett attractive is not just her smooth glowing complexion, or her Doe eyes, or not even the (naturally formed) Cupid’s Bow Lips. Scarlett has that implausible combination of being Aloof, Alluring and (possibly) Available. She doesn’t set all her qualities on the Walgreens’ countertop like Miley Cyrus, for all the customers to see and fully know. As D. Rumsfeld would say, There is an ‘known unknown’ about Miss Scarlett. That adds to the excitement. I think that she will age gracefully, like Sharon Stone or Catherine Deneuve.