No, it was stolen from you.
The thief has broken a commandment, which is between them and God.
I had a few hundred stolen from me by a very vile man one time years ago.
It’s done, from my perspective, no way I’ll ever see the guy again.
It happened before I was saved, so it bothered me a lot for a while. Then I just forgot about it. Who dwells on such things ?
If he was converted to Christ and theoretically found me, I could understand such a person wanting to pay back what they stole. But it’s of course the soul that really matters, not the money stolen from me. I’m not waiting for this payment ! Then, after my conversion I recalled the event and saw it in a new light, where I was preserved through a situation by the Lord even before I converted.
Take the case of someone owing you money, a friend. If they’re “down and out”, you don’t bother them about it.
But in all such cases, these people ultimately have to reckon with God.
These are easy cases. What about if a person perpetrated some violence on someone you love - and they go unpunished by the law ? That’s difficult to just “forget”, to not seek vengeance. That takes some serious amount of faith, IMHO.
What are you asserting “no” against?
Of course it was stolen.
But I can still give it to God.
I can’t give somebody else’s life to God, so your counterexample fails.
I think it is very telling about the pinched state of YOUR soul that you want to be prickly and conditional about it.