Tony was an idiot to tell everyone he is a cop. He’ll be ousted over that.
Tony was just so pleased with himself after setting up Jeremiah that he had to spit it all out. I’ll bet he is the master of planting evidence as a cop as he seemed to know just what to do to Jeremiah to make his tribe suspicious of him.
And of course Jeremiah was so stupid to fall for it. Didn’t he watch last season and the way Monica just threw the clues in the fire.
He should have thrown the clue right in the fire and not put it in his pocket and shown it to the others when he got back to camp and for sure not given it back to Tony afterwards.