Caleb Johnson
America's choice is "Don't Want To Miss A Thing" by Aerosmith. The only good thing to come out of that "Armageddon" movie.
He doesn't move this time. No running or flailing all over the stage. Sings the song in one spot. Good. But he's been better.
Jlo: That was a challenging song for you. I felt that. You sang it beautifully. You took it more into a ballad. There's no way you can match what Steven Tyler does. But you did a beautiful job. I got goosies.
Harry: Every week you show us you have this amazing strong powerful voice. (quibbles about staring into the camera) You need to create this crazy electricity. I thought it was a strong performance. Could have been better if you sang to us (in the audience, not the camera)
Keith: You have an incredible range, incredible abilty. (says feeling should lead his ability--thought it was the other way around tonight. But he liked it)
Meat Loaf: I don't know if I would have picked that exact song. I wanted to show a tender side and not do the big Aerosmith rock ballad.